4 Reasons Why Roof Replacement Is Better Than Repairs
TONY • February 2, 2022

Your roofing system plays a major role in protecting the integrity of your home. When you experience roofing issues, you will need to perform either a complete roof replacement or a simple repair. However, when it comes to extensive roof damage, your roofer may recommend replacing your roof to prevent further problems.

Hire Pros for a Painting Job

Here are four reasons why it’s best to replace your roof instead of making repairs.

1. Your Roof Is Old

If your current roofing system is nearing the end of its lifespan, this may be a good indication that you need to replace your roof. Replacing your roof instead of repeatedly repairing the issues is worth the investment, especially if you’re planning to sell your home soon. As such, you must know the age of your roof. If it’s more than 20 to 25 years old, be sure to consult your roofer for a replacement.

2. Your Roof Is Leaking

One of the most common reasons why homeowners call a roofing company is because of leakage problems. You might be experiencing a leaking roof if you’ve noticed water stains in your home that run across ceilings or run down your walls. If you fail to fix this issue, leaks may lead to mold, rotting roof framing and sheathing or wet insulation. In worst cases, your roof may end up sagging because of trapped moisture. Thus, you will need to replace your roof.

3. Your Roof Has Structural Damage

There are two main categories of roof damage: aesthetic and structural. Aesthetic damage means that your roofing material has deteriorated in appearance, which may affect your home’s curb appeal. Meanwhile, structural damage typically involves more extensive issues, such as cracked asphalt shingles or dented roofing components. If your roof is suffering from structural damage, it’s best to replace your roof.

4. You Often Experience Bad Weather

Another thing to consider is your geographical area. Extreme bad weather, such as hailstorms, hurricanes or tornadoes, can affect your roofing system’s long-term performance. If your current roof cannot withstand damage from hail or falling debris, you may want to consider replacing it with more durable roofing material. While a roof repair seems to be the cheaper option, there may be instances wherein the damage reappears even after repairing. Thus, replacing your roof is a more practical choice.


For more roofing inquiries, turn to Tony’s Roof Care. Our highly skilled roofing contractors provide quality roofing services, including roof maintenance and more. Call us today at (253) 881-8743, or fill out our contact form to set an appointment.


Filed Under: roofing POST TAGS: ROOF LEAKS | ROOF REPAIR | ROOF REPLACEMENT

Recent Posts

April 20, 2025
Wondering how long does an asphalt roof last? Discover what really affects its lifespan—from shingle type to weather and maintenance.
April 20, 2025
Learn what is roof sheathing, why it matters, and how it impacts your roof's structure, safety, and replacement cost.
By Mitch Koch April 3, 2025
Thinking about a new roof? It’s a significant investment and one of the first questions homeowners ask Tony’s Roofcare, Inc. is, “ How much does a new roof cost ?” We understand that budgeting is crucial for any project as large as a new roof. While providing an exact figure is impossible without a personalized assessment, we can offer a general overview of what goes into the costs for a new roof. What Factors Influence Roof Costs? Before we dive into pricing information, it’s important to understand the factors that will impact the final price: The size of your roof. The complexity of your roof. This includes multiple levels, dormers, intricate designs and more. The roofing materials you choose. Homeowners have the option of asphalt shingles, metal roofing, tile and wood shakes and all have varying price points. The cost of labor. These costs vary based on your location and the experience your roofing contractor brings to the table. Underlayment and flashing. You will want to invest in quality materials and ensure proper installation because these are essential for a long-lasting roof for your investment. Removal and disposal of old roofing materials adds to the overall cost of the project. A difficult to access roof may increase labor costs. Addressing underlying issues like damaged decking or framing will add to the cost of the roof replacement. General cost ranges – keep in mind these are ever-changing and are only averages Asphalt shingles are the most common and affordable option. For an “average-sized” home the costs could begin at around $10,000. Metal roofs are the most durable and long-lasting option and are becoming more popular in recent years. The cost for an “average-home” size for a metal roof could begin at around $18,000. Tile or slate roofing is a premium option; these materials are great for historic buildings or homes concerned about moisture problems. These are the most expensive option and for an “average-sized” home the starting costs would be around $25,000. What are other considerations for a new roof? Any of the price options are rough estimates. Actual costs vary and depend on your roof, its condition, the roofing material you choose, where you live and other factors. Get more than one quote from a reputable roofing contractor. If the prices are vastly different ask for an explanation on the differences. Don’t shop for the lowest price for your roof. Consider the roofing contractor’s experience and reputation. Because a roof is such a significant expense, you want to get the absolute best. Inquire about warranties. Remember, a low price could sometimes mean low quality work or materials, and that could cost you more to fix in the future. Your roof is your home’s protection from the outside elements and you want the best protection your budget allows. Get a personalized estimate from Tony’s Roofcare The best way to determine the cost of your roof replacement is to schedule a free, no obligation estimate with us. We’ll assess your home’s unique needs, provide expert recommendations and give you a detailed quote so you can make an informed decision on a roof replacement. Investing in a new roof is a significant decision – and investment – let us help you get the best bang for your budget. At Tony’s Roofcare, we’re committed to providing top-quality roofing services, including flashing replacement and free inspections. Don’t wait until a leak becomes a major problem—contact us today to ensure your roof is in the best shape possible.
March 7, 2025
Learn what flashing on a roof is and why it’s essential for leak prevention. Get expert roof flashing services from Tony’s Roof Care today.
March 7, 2025
Discover how long a metal roof lasts, its benefits, and maintenance tips. Trust Tony’s Roof Care for expert installation and long-term durability.
By Jen Woslager February 15, 2025
When it comes to installing new siding on your home, choosing the right materials is crucial for ensuring long-lasting protection and efficiency. In Parkland, WA, Tony's Roofcare consistently chooses Tyvek HomeWrap for its superior quality and the extensive benefits it offers to homeowners. Here's why Tyvek HomeWrap is our preferred choice for new siding projects.
By Jen Woslager January 14, 2025
Explore roofing options for Kent's climate. Learn about materials, maintenance, and local codes to make the best choice for your home.
By Jen Woslager December 30, 2024
Learn how exterior roof issues lead to interior damage and explore preventive measures in Tacoma, WA.